Looking Back on Late Nights
Since I was ‘allowed’ to stay up late (past 11pm, which was probably age 16) on weeknights, I’ve watched late night television talk shows. It started, of course, with Johnny Carson, who is probably deserving of the praise that’s been heaped upon him since he stopped doing television. Carson naturally led to watching Letterman - if I was still awake at that point, which was usually only on Fridays - before he jumped to CBS.
The distinction of changing networks for Dave’s show isn’t really the turning point for the quality or relevance of his show, although his days on NBC had a much more independant and low budget feel to them. For its time, Late Night with David Letterman was actually quite subversive and strayed from mainstream humour on a regular basis. It wasn’t until four or five years into his reign on CBS that he started ‘dialing it in’ most nights, and the steady dumbing down of his audience didn’t encourage him to do more than just show up, go through his rehearsed questions, and call it a night. Once sketches involving Mujibur & Sirajul or Rupert Gee disappeared, there really wasn’t much to set Dave’s show apart anymore. I never enjoyed Jay Leno, and in fact he’s a horrible interviewer (even if it is, like 99% of Dave’s shows, totally rehearsed) and his monologue is lowest-common-denominator humour. So today, unless I find a guest on Letterman’s show that I like, the 11:35 time slot is a miss.
The last decade has rightfully belonged to the ‘late late show’ time slot, with Conan really hitting his stride a year or two into his time at Dave’s old post. However I think Conan fizzled out much faster than Dave ever did - oddly, once his sidekick Andy Richter left, things just became very dull and Conan really seems to have run out of anything funny to say during interviews. And, unlike Dave, when political people come to visit, Conan’s really out of his element. There is the rare show when Dave has a veteran newscaster or political guest on, and he turns on at least a little intelligence.
My favourite hosts of the recent past have been in the 12:35 slot on CBS. A few years ago, it was Craig Kilborn hosting The Late Late Show. There’s no question Kilborn thought highly of himself, and his ego sometimes showed, but his show was mostly smart and had a very laid back feel to it - perfect for something post-midnight. I always enjoyed Five Questions and especially Yambo, which was a fun trivia-elimination game played with the night’s guests. Kilborn only lasted 5 years at his post, and judging by other late night hosts, he probably got out before the inevitable slide of creativity that every other host has fallen into.
Today the Late Late Show is hosted by a new Craig: Scottish actor Craig Ferguson now has the reins, and for the most part he does a great job. He’s got tons of energy and genuinely seems to enjoy his job - perhaps even is thankful for it - and his bizarre sketches of Aquaman, Angela Landsbury, Prince Charles and others usually devolve into complete silliness and it’s hard not to laugh just for this reason. Throw in the show’s final bit, “What Did We Learn on the Show Tonight, Craig?”, where the host looks back on the show and just lets his mind wander, are usually priceless. Ferguson has been the host since 2005, which means his run really ought to last three or four more years before it’s time for him to move on. Who knows, maybe Letterman will retire when his eleventy-million dollar contract is up (for the record, I predict Conan’s move into Leno’s spot, coming in the next year or so, to be a complete disaster, so Dave might hang in there just to feel some sort of final triumph over NBC).
